Perspective Storytelling and evidence

Most swans have a name badge

One specific story beats a general one every time. But the most specific thing most places have is not a thing at all.

Rob Dunphy 6 minute read
The Silver Swan automaton at the Bowes Museum, a life-sized silver swan on a bed of silver leaves, with a gallery of paintings behind it
The Silver Swan, Bowes Museum. Image courtesy of the Bowes Museum.

There is a silver swan at the Bowes Museum. It was made in 1773. Once a day it comes to life, turns its head, catches a silver fish and swallows it. Then it stops.

It is, by some distance, the most watched thing in County Durham online. More than the Cathedral. More than anything a marketing budget has ever produced there.

It has never been on a marketing course.

I spoke about that swan last week at the Visit County Durham industry conference, in a room of around a hundred attractions and hospitality businesses. The conference theme was the power of story. My argument was simple: one specific story beats a general one, every time.

How a place is seen is often not how it is perceived

We look at two things when we work with a destination. They answer different questions.

The first is what people watch. We track video content across TikTok, Instagram and YouTube and where relevant map it to the places it names, so we can see which spots are gaining attention and how fast. That tells you how a place is seen, mostly by people who have not been there yet.

The second is what visitors say afterwards. We score online reviews across a consistent set of dimensions so the same question can be asked every quarter. That tells you how a place is perceived, by people who have been and formed a personal view.

Put the two side by side and the interesting part is never where they agree. It is where they do not.

Almost every destination we look at has something visitors rate highly and nobody films. It is usually sitting there in the review data, quietly, while the marketing talks about something else entirely.

What attention actually looks like

Online attention in a place is almost never evenly spread. One story tends to take most of it while everything else shares what is left.

one story

Charming is not a strategy

Here is the problem with how most places describe themselves. Open the websites of any historic region and you will find the same handful of words. Charming. Steeped in history. Hidden gem. A warm welcome.

All of these are true whilst none of them are distinguishing or unique. If your website says steeped in history, so do many more that are all competing for the same weekend audience.

The swan works because it is absurdly specific. A 250 year old mechanical bird with a daily routine. You cannot confuse that with anywhere else, which is exactly why people film it.

During our analysis we found a bar with a sign reading, roughly, probably the smallest gin bar in the world. That is the same instinct. It is not claiming to be the best. It is claiming to be one specific thing and it has put that claim on a wall where people photograph it.

My favourite example of this is not British at all. In 2016 the Faroe Islands strapped solar powered 360 degree cameras to free roaming sheep, because the islands had more sheep than people and nobody from Google had turned up to map the islands. ‘Sheep View’. Within two weeks the hotels in the capital were sold out, within two months Google Street View gave in and sent a crew.

Nobody arrived at that idea by writing down the word charming.

Close-up of the Silver Swan's head and neck, showing the detail of the silver feathers and the fish in its beak
Specific enough that you could not mistake it for anywhere else. Image courtesy of the Bowes Museum.

My experience around the event highlighted something clear to me

I drove over the night before. Low cloud, long country lanes, the kind of visibility where you are grateful for a sign appearing when it should.

Driving into the venue in the morning, a man in a hi-viz told me exactly where to park and someone would meet me beyond the car park. The night before, a receptionist stayed friendly and unflustered while the phone rang and rang and rang. Staff walked me through every step of a site I would still be lost in. Two people I had never met made sure I was comfortable with the lectern before I went on.

I had come to tell a room to find its swan but the people kept showing me a clear answer.

None of those people appear in visitor statistics. They are not in an economic impact model. They are not in an occupancy figure. Every standard measure the sector uses is blind to them.

Except they are everywhere in the online reviews. Once you have scored a few thousand of them you notice that visitors rarely write about architecture. They write about a person. A server in a hidden café A volunteer who made their day. Someone who went and found an umbrella.

The swan is a wonderful sight and a very good story but during this insightful day I realised that most swans have a name badge.

A note on levies, since it came up

Simon Calder spoke before me and was asked about visitor levies. His answer was more useful than the usual arguments. If a place is genuinely overrun, tax it and put the money into the community carrying the cost. He named the obvious examples. If a place is not overrun, a levy can look like free money and deserves real caution.

I have written about levies before. This sits in honest tension with my own position rather than neatly alongside it. My argument has always been about evidence rather than whether to charge. A place that is not overrun still needs to know what it has before it decides anything.

Simon Calder is right that these are two different problems. One is about managing attention you already have. The other is about earning attention you do not. Most of the UK is in the second group and talks as though it is in the first.

What to do with this

If you run a place or a business in one, the useful question is not what makes you special. Everyone answers that question with the same words.

Better questions: what do visitors already praise that you never mention? What is the one thing here that genuinely exists nowhere else? And who on your team do people write about by name?

You can answer the first two with your own reviews and an afternoon of speaking to your customers and team. The third one you probably already know.

Rob Dunphy is director of Evidence Agency, an independent visitor and community research consultancy working with destination and place managers, local authorities and protected landscapes across the UK.

Seen and perceived

What is your swan?

We track what people watch about a place and score what visitors say once they have been, then show you where the two disagree. That gap is usually where the story you are not telling has been sitting all along.

Start a conversation